(469) 751-4018
Texas doesn’t go easy on roofs. Lone Star State residents can trust that extreme temperatures and weather conditions aren’t going anywhere, so choosing the right roofing material is a big deal. The roof you select can influence everything from your home’s curbside appeal to its longevity and maintenance needs.
You can see a comparison of all major roofing materials in our comprehensive roofing guide. But today, we’ll compare two of the most durable materials available: slate and metal roofing. Here’s what you need to know.
Slate Roofing
Slate roofing is known for its natural beauty and long lifespan — often considered among the finest roofing materials available. Made from metamorphic rock, slate tiles have a natural and elegant appearance, and due to the durability of stone, the roof can last up to a century with the right care. However, it comes with a high upfront cost and requires professional installation due to the weight and fragility of the material. The heaviness of slate also poses an additional issue: a home’s framing must be able to hold up a slate roof, which some structures will not be able to do.
Metal Roofing
One of the few other materials in the league of slate, metal roofing is also a great way to improve curb appeal and protect homes from severe weather. From steel to copper, metal roofs come in a variety of styles and finishes that can add a sleek modern touch. While metal doesn’t last quite as long as slate, it’s hard to beat when it comes to high winds and severe hail, making it ideal for Texas climates.
Comparison: Slate vs. Metal Roofing
Cost Effectiveness
Compared to other materials like asphalt and wood, both metal and slate roofing fall in the “very high” cost range. Compared to one another, slate roofing is quite a bit more expensive than metal. This is partly because it’s so heavy and challenging to install. However, because slate can last up to a century, it’s hard to argue that it’s anything but a good investment.
On the other hand, metal roofing is the comparably more budget-friendly choice. Maybe it doesn’t last as long, but metal roofs do offer better protection against hail, have a lower upfront cost, and provide more energy efficiency.
Toughness
While slate can last between 70 to 100 years thanks to the hardiness of its stone composition, metal roofs generally last between 50 to 70s years. But that’s not the whole story. Slate is also more prone to cracking due to heavy impacts, like severe hail.
But make no mistake: Slate is very durable compared to wood or asphalt roofs — it’s only in comparison to metal that it’s overshadowed. Metal is highly resistant to denting or cracking. Both materials are resistant to fire, and neither have costly and constant maintenance, such as wood shingles.
Aesthetics
Slate offers a timeless and natural elegance that’s hard to beat, but ultimately, its color options are limited. That said, on the right home, an authentic slate roof can do wonders for curb appeal.
Metal roofing offers more versatility in terms of style (like copper or aluminum), with additional finish options. Metal roofs can even mimic the look of some traditional materials, like tile or wood.
We’re Here to Help
Need an expert opinion? Don’t hesitate to contact the DFW Roofers team with your questions about choosing the right roof. Call us at (469) 751-4018 or schedule an appointment through our online appointment form.